↓ 跳过正文

Punctuated Equilibrium

Volatility in Evidence Use: A Computational Analysis of Punctuated Equilibrium Theory

PSJ 54/4 2026-11-05 Original Volatility in Evidence Use: A Computational Analysis of Punctuated Equilibrium Theory Stefani Langehennig Abstract ABSTRACT How does the use of evidence in policy documents change over time, and what explains differences between stable, incremental, and abrupt shifts in its use? This study introduces a computational framework to evaluate change in evidence use across Congressional Research Service (CRS) reports. Using a combination of large language models and supervised machine learning, each document is scored on its alignment with evidence‐based policymaking principles and aggregated to the policy‐topic level. The results show that most policy areas exhibit gradual change, while punctuated shifts are less common and highly variable. Public salience is associated with punctuated evidence‐use trajectories, while media and executive attention are associated primarily with gradual change; partisan control plays a limited role once attention and institutional demand are taken into account. Substantial variation remains across policy topics, with areas such as Macroeconomics and Government Operations exhibiting relatively high dispersion in evidence‐use scores. These findings demonstrate that evidence use in policymaking is dynamic and attention‐sensitive over time.

Artificial Intelligence and Punctuated Equilibrium: Shaping Government Attention in the Digital Age

PAR — 2026-10-02 Original Artificial Intelligence and Punctuated Equilibrium: Shaping Government Attention in the Digital Age Shuo Chen, Yiran Li, Yuzheng Wang Abstract ABSTRACT How do government attention and policy agendas shift when information constraints are relaxed through technological advancement? Punctuated equilibrium theory links agenda‐setting dynamics to governments' limited information‐processing capabilities, yet we know little about whether and how technology improvement such as artificial intelligence (AI) influences policy agendas. This article proposes a conditional digital punctuation framework to specify the conditions under which technological advancements drive agenda shifts. Using China's implementation of AI initiatives as a quasi‐natural experiment, we find that government attention exhibits a punctuated pattern. AI increases technology‐focused attention, signaling incremental changes, while having minimal impact on general government attention. This selective impact stems from AI's asymmetric effects on information processing. Specifically, AI significantly increases the procurement‐based indicator of information quantity, which is associated with greater attention to technology sectors; however, no significant change is observed in the corresponding indicator of information quality, consistent with its limited impact on general government attention.