↓ 跳过正文

Productivity Performance Matrix

Assessing performance in collaborative governance networks: testing the Productivity Performance Matrix

PMR — pp. 1-27 2026-10-22 Original Assessing performance in collaborative governance networks: testing the Productivity Performance Matrix Siobhan McQuaid, Mary Lee Rhodes Abstract Performance measurement for collaborative governance presents significant challenges both practically and theoretically. With the goal of refining theory grounded in empirical application, we use Emerson and Nabatchi’s Productivity Performance Matrix and their Integrative Framework for Collaborative Governance, to examine data from a five-year longitudinal comparative case study of collaborative governance regimes (CGRs) in three European cities.Our research showed that the indicators of the Productivity Performance Matrix (PPM) had significant relevance to actual performance outcomes observed in the CGRs studied, albeit with some modifications. Proposed modifications include removing the ‘participant organization’ as a distinct level of analysis in network-centred evaluations, reconceptualization of equity as ‘perceived equity’, distinguishing between internal and external legitimacy, and shifting from ‘sustainability’ to ‘systemic change’ as a performance indicator for adaptation. The refinement of performance indicators and the improved conceptual coherence between the PPM and the Integrative Framework are the primary contributions of this work.