↓ 跳过正文

Participatory Budgeting

A Model of Agency Behavior in Participatory Budgeting: A Resource Dependence Perspective

JPART — 2026-09-08 Original A Model of Agency Behavior in Participatory Budgeting: A Resource Dependence Perspective Seunghyun Kim Abstract Abstract Based on resource dependence theory, this article theorizes why government agencies adopt citizen proposals in participatory budgeting. Agencies depend on the executive budget office and the legislature for budget approval, which makes them face uncertainty in securing budgets from these political principals. In this context, agencies can adopt citizen proposals to present their requests as reflecting citizen demands, thereby increasing the probability of approval. Building on this logic, this study argues that the greater the uncertainty agencies face in their dependencies on principals, the more likely they are to depend on proposals. This argument is tested using multilevel mixed-effects logistic regression based on citizen proposals (N = 3,609) submitted through Korea’s national participatory budgeting initiative from 2020 through 2023. The results show that agencies with less financial support from the legislature or those with smaller budgets are more likely to adopt proposals, as they face greater uncertainty due to unstable budgetary flows or fewer response options to manage resource instability. Agencies are also more likely to adopt proposals when they previously secured greater funding through proposal adoption, but this effect weakens for larger-budget agencies or those receiving greater legislative support. These findings emphasize the strategic nature of proposal adoption and the role of resource dependence in agency responses to proposals.

Varieties of Participation and Investment in Local Public Goods: Evidence from an RCT in Kenya

JOP — 2026-04-01 Original Varieties of Participation and Investment in Local Public Goods: Evidence from an RCT in Kenya Tara Grillos, Michael Touchton Abstract This is a pre-registered report that has been accepted in principle at the Journal of Politics to be published after collection and analysis of the data. Citizen participation is widely believed to improve development outcomes by increasing participants’ willingness-to-invest in development projects. Participatory budgeting is one of the most popular ways to engage the public in policy making. These programs have spread rapidly across the Global South but have rarely been evaluated. Outcomes related to participant behavior likely depend on the specific procedures used to encourage and structure participation. Within the context of participatory budgeting in rural Kenya (a ‘hard test’ of these hypotheses), we randomly assign three commonly used group decision procedures to select development projects at the village level, which are then implemented in each village. In this registered report, we compare treatments across villages in terms of participation in a “community action day” and other behavioral measures of public goods investment. This represents our first step toward assessing how differing participatory designs promote collective action to maintain projects, thereby promoting sustainable development.