↓ 跳过正文

Legitimacy

When Do Citizens Resist the Use of AI Algorithms in Public Policy? Theory and Evidence

JOP 88/4 pp. 1301-1317 2026-10-01 Original When Do Citizens Resist the Use of AI Algorithms in Public Policy? Theory and Evidence Shir Raviv Abstract In recent years, there has been a significant rise in the use of algorithmic decision-making systems (ADS) to assist or replace human decision-making in a wide range of policy areas as policing, criminal sentencing, and social welfare assistance. How do citizens view the incorporation of this technology in guiding high-stakes decisions? I introduce a new theory to explain the conditions under which citizens view ADS as legitimate, fair, and accurate, and test it using data from original experiments embedded in a national U.S. survey. I show that across a wide range of policy domains, citizens exhibit aversion to the use of ADS in decisions that are seen as designed to sanction rather than to assist, and when they are required to make inferences about individuals rather than collectives. Evidence from a second experiment suggests that the employment of ADS in such contexts can significantly undermine the legitimacy of the policy actions they inform. Together, the study offers a framework to identify where AI-based tools will be deemed appropriate and where they might trigger backlash, highlighting the importance of accounting for citizens’ values in AI development and implementation to maintain legitimacy and democratic accountability.

Beyond dyads: an ecosystem approach to third-sector legitimacy in public services

PMR — pp. 1-39 2026-04-27 Original Beyond dyads: an ecosystem approach to third-sector legitimacy in public services Alina Khakimova Abstract Third-sector organizations (TSOs) play an increasing role in public service provision, yet their legitimacy remains underexplored beyond dyadic and organization-centric accounts. This paper develops an ecosystem-based explanation by integrating legitimacy theory with the Public Service Ecosystem (PSE) framework. Drawing on a qualitative multi-case study of four TSOs delivering children’s services in Scotland, the findings show that legitimacy emerges through interdependencies among actors and institutions across macro, meso, and micro levels. Three mechanisms are identified: institutional translation, leadership coordination, and temporal reconfiguration. The study conceptualizes legitimacy as an emergent, cross-level process and a central dynamic shaping coordination and participation within PSEs.