↓ 跳过正文

Federalism

Emulate the Leader? Explaining Crisis Policy Change in the Canadian Federal System

GOV 39/4 2026-11-01 Original Emulate the Leader? Explaining Crisis Policy Change in the Canadian Federal System Liddell Hastings Abstract ABSTRACT In times of crises, do governments coordinate or do they make their own choices independent of what others do? Convergence of COVID‐19 policy at the beginning of the pandemic has been widely studied in federal countries. Yet, there is limited literature looking at the mechanisms that made policy between jurisdictions so similar. Utilizing Canada's decentralized federal system, this paper posits that convergence can be explained by a process of policy diffusion through emulation and a series of leader‐follower relationships. Drawing on the policy diffusion literature, this paper proposes three hypotheses for why some jurisdictions take on leadership roles in crisis policy while others follow. Synthesized as proximity, capacity, and urgency, these hypotheses are tested using a series of pairwise vector autoregressions identifying significant leader‐follower relationships between Canadian provinces. The findings suggest that policy primarily flowed from only a small number of large provinces (Quebec and Ontario), lending partial evidence, but also exceptions to the hypotheses proposed.

Does level of government and messaging influence public evacuations? Examining public compliance and agency trust

PMR — pp. 1-23 2026-09-27 Original Does level of government and messaging influence public evacuations? Examining public compliance and agency trust Jaclyn Piatak, Colt Jensen Abstract Extreme weather events are increasing globally, yet research on how public leadership messaging and the level of government delivering crisis communications influence public compliance and institutional trust remains limited. Drawing on public leadership theory and federalism research, we employ a 2 × 3 survey experiment embedded in the 2023 US Cooperative Election Study (N = 409) to examine how messaging style (authoritarian versus democratic) and the level of government agency (federal, state, or local) influence evacuation intent and agency trust. We find that messaging from the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) increases evacuation intent, despite local governments being legally responsible for issuing evacuation orders. Democratic, or collective, messaging is associated with greater trust in agency. However, trust is more strongly associated with pre-existing individual orientations, public service motivation, and political ideology, than with one-time communication cues. Findings have implications for crisis communication strategy, public leadership, and intergovernmental coordination in emergency management.