Brake or bridge? The dual impact of clientelism on hospital corporatization in Iran
PMR — pp. 1-32 2026-09-15 Original Brake or bridge? The dual impact of clientelism on hospital corporatization in Iran
Maryam Zahmatkesh, Ian Kirkpatrick
Abstract
Public management reforms like corporatization often fail due to a lack of cultural and institutional compatibility, leading to divergence from globally prescribed reform models rather than convergence towards their intended managerial and organizational outcomes. While global templates prioritize managerial autonomy and efficiency, national ‘cultural ecologies’ filter these changes, sometimes creating deceptive window dressing to secure external legitimacy. This paper addresses a significant gap in current research by exploring how social relationships governed by clientelism – integral to the cultural ecologies of many countries – also impact on reform implementation. Using the Iranian healthcare sector as a case study, the paper investigates whether clientelism inevitably derails corporatization (the brake) or serves as an inherent cultural component that managers must navigate to achieve organizational goals (the bridge).