PSJ 54/4 2026-11-05
Original Volatility in Evidence Use: A Computational Analysis of Punctuated Equilibrium Theory
Stefani Langehennig
Abstract
ABSTRACT How does the use of evidence in policy documents change over time, and what explains differences between stable, incremental, and abrupt shifts in its use? This study introduces a computational framework to evaluate change in evidence use across Congressional Research Service (CRS) reports. Using a combination of large language models and supervised machine learning, each document is scored on its alignment with evidence‐based policymaking principles and aggregated to the policy‐topic level. The results show that most policy areas exhibit gradual change, while punctuated shifts are less common and highly variable. Public salience is associated with punctuated evidence‐use trajectories, while media and executive attention are associated primarily with gradual change; partisan control plays a limited role once attention and institutional demand are taken into account. Substantial variation remains across policy topics, with areas such as Macroeconomics and Government Operations exhibiting relatively high dispersion in evidence‐use scores. These findings demonstrate that evidence use in policymaking is dynamic and attention‐sensitive over time.
PNAS 123/44 pp. e2623869123-e2623869123 2026-10-26 Original Evaluation of possibly fabricated references in 500,000 science, engineering, and computing papers
Maxim Topaz, Pallavi Gupta, Zhihong Zhang, Laura‐Maria Peltonen
PNAS 123/44 pp. e2407568122-e2407568122 2026-10-26 Original Equity dimensions of future vulnerabilities to climate hazards: Long-term spatial population projections for New York City consistent with Shared Socioeconomic Pathways
PNAS 123/42 2026-10-15
Original Estimating the threat of AI-agent responding across online survey platforms
Grace Zhang, Robert Walatka, Stephanie Y. Chen, Alexander Kentaro Moore, Oleg Urminsky, Kianté A. Fernandez, Andrea Löw, Jonathan Elliot Bogard, Craig R. Fox
PSJ 54/4 2026-10-06
Original Making Policy Evidence Traceable: A Modular Preregistration Framework for Policy Evaluation
Yiyun Xia, Tianhao Zhao, Yuhao Ba
Abstract
ABSTRACT Preregistration is increasingly used in policy research, but its value depends on whether preregistered commitments can be clearly linked to reported analyses. Policy studies often involve multiple outcomes, evolving administrative data, consequential design and analytic choices, and adaptive implementation, making it difficult to distinguish prespecified tests from subsequent adjustments. This research note proposes a modular, policy‐oriented companion framework for using existing preregistration infrastructure. The framework combines a shared core that defines the estimand, outcomes, and identification strategy with design‐specific modules for field experiments, administrative‐data quasi‐experiments, and behavioral policy trials. Together, the components serve two purposes: claim traceability, by linking reported results to the original plan, and governed adaptation, by providing a transparent record of changes made during the study. The aim is not to prevent adaptation, but to show which analyses were prespecified, which were revised through documented amendments, and which were developed later. This approach aims to improve the interpretability and transparency of policy research while remaining feasible in applied policy settings.
PNAS 123/40 2026-10-01
Original Generalized Taylor’s law for infinite-mean heavy-tailed data under dependence and heterogeneity
Pok Him Cheng, Joel E. Cohen, Hok Kan Ling, Sheung Chi Phillip Yam
JOP 88/4 pp. 1287-1300 2026-10-01 Original Express Yourself (Ideologically): Legislators’ Ideal Points Across Audiences
JOP 88/4 pp. 1437-1449 2026-10-01 Original Electoral Predictors of Polling Errors
Sina Chen, John Körtner, Jens Wiederspohn, Peter Selb
JOP 88/4 pp. 1336-1353 2026-10-01 Original Editor’s Choice: Measuring Candidate Quality Using Local Newspaper Endorsements
Kevin DeLuca
Abstract
I construct a measure of candidate quality differentials using local newspaper endorsements. I argue that political endorsements made by newspapers can be used as expert opinions that reflect both a newspaper's partisan bias as well as quality differences between the candidates in an election. Using a dataset of 21,094 local newspaper endorsements, I simultaneously estimate the quality differences between candidates in 6,432 elections, along with a dynamic measure of the partisan bias of 368 local newspapers. After validating the endorsement-based measures of quality and bias, I use the candidate quality differential measure to reexamine the relationship between candidate quality, incumbency, and election results. I conclude with a discussion of how the new endorsement-based measures have a strong potential to help advance our understanding of the importance of candidate quality in electoral politics and governance in the United States.
JOP 88/4 pp. 1668-1673 2026-10-01 Original Conversations with a Concern-Addressing Chatbot Increased COVID-19 Vaccination Intentions Among Social Media Users in Kenya and Nigeria
Leah R. Rosenzweig, Molly Offer-Westort