↓ 跳过正文

比较政治

When Can Clientelism Serve Democratic Ends? A Democratic Theory of Distributive Politics

APSR — pp. 1-15 2026-10-08 Original When Can Clientelism Serve Democratic Ends? A Democratic Theory of Distributive Politics SAMUEL ELY BAGG, UDIT BHATIA Abstract This article employs normative democratic theory to examine a counterintuitive suggestion raised repeatedly by empirical scholars of clientelism: namely, that practices of particularistic exchange might sometimes serve democratic ends. Certainly, most particularistic practices are widely agreed to undermine democracy, on both intrinsic and instrumental grounds. Yet some observers resist blanket condemnation—and in particular, many highlight the redeeming democratic virtues of certain practices that seem to facilitate collective organization among disempowered groups. Drawing on “realist” approaches to democratic theory, we vindicate this basic insight while clarifying its scope conditions. Countervailing power is a crucial democratic priority, and programmatic methods of promoting it sometimes face serious obstacles: as when clientelist practices are deeply entrenched, or incumbents capture the tools of programmatic competition. Under such conditions, we conclude, democracy-seeking leaders may justifiably employ particularistic practices to promote countervailing power—but only if they respect five constraints tethering them strictly to that goal.

Gender Justice Activism and Strategic Abeyance in Post-2020 Hong Kong

JCC — pp. 1-18 2026-10-07 Original Gender Justice Activism and Strategic Abeyance in Post-2020 Hong Kong Mengzhe Feng Abstract This article examines the post-2020 transformation of Hong Kong’s gender justice movement amid autocratization. Drawing on 20 in-depth interviews and public materials, it develops a profile-shaped framework of abeyance to demonstrate that political risks and adaptive possibilities are distributed unevenly across civil society. The study argues that, as a lower-profile sector, gender justice activism faces less direct repression, retains institutional space unavailable to higher-profile pro-democracy movement, and absorbs redirected civic energy. It then demonstrates how activists adapt through self-limitation, arena shifts, and reorganizing structures to exploit this tolerable position. This delicate navigation allows them to remain active without being reclassified as threats in the eyes of authorities. The findings offer broader insights into authoritarian governance, contemporary civil society survival, and movement adaptation in non-democratic contexts.

When women lead: local political representation and pro-women institutions

PMR — pp. 1-27 2026-10-05 Original When women lead: local political representation and pro-women institutions Marylis Fantoni, Adalmir de Oliveira Gomes, Claudia N. Avellaneda Abstract Whether women in office govern differently from men is well documented; whether they govern differently for women is not. The latter is the crux of active representation theory, which expects representatives to act for those they mirror: does electing women change what governments do for women? We investigate the relationship between electing female mayors and councilors and the existence of Pro-Women Institutions across all 5,565 cities of Brazil during four election cycles (2008, 2012, 2016 and 2020). Our results partially support the active representation relationship. While female mayors’ presence increases the likelihood of pro-women institutions, local councilors either do not or are negatively linked to them. Robustness checks through a regression discontinuity design corroborate these findings, and heterogeneous treatment effects on race paint a wider picture about intersectionality. Our findings highlight how female elected representatives might achieve substantial change for their female constituents in local government.

External Threats and Support for Military Service under Authoritarian Rule

JOP — 2026-10-05 Original External Threats and Support for Military Service under Authoritarian Rule Roya Izadi Abstract As international conflicts escalate, states are increasingly turning to conscription and broader public participation in national defense. This article examines how acute external threats influence public attitudes toward military service. Leveraging original survey data from Iran, fielded before and after the unprecedented April 13, 2024 missile exchange with Israel, I use matching techniques to compare responses across the two periods. Individuals surveyed after the attack were significantly more likely to support mandatory male conscription and to support women’s military service. Importantly, support rose even though conscription is widely unpopular in peacetime and despite Iran’s gender hierarchies. These findings demonstrate that external threats can legitimize coercion in contexts of regime distrust and reconfigure gender boundaries around military participation. The study contributes to research on public perceptions of war, coercion, and militarization by highlighting how geopolitical shocks recalibrate the boundaries of both state authority and gendered citizenship.

The Representation Trap: How Minority Power Shapes Electoral Politics in India

APSR — pp. 1-20 2026-10-02 Original The Representation Trap: How Minority Power Shapes Electoral Politics in India FEYAAD ALLIE Abstract Liberal democracy requires that minority groups be represented in politics. This article argues that minority representation can also generate headwinds for political inclusion by dividing the minority group and consolidating the dominant group. I study the combination of these processes, termed the representation trap, through a mixed-methods examination of Muslims in India. Analyses of election results and an original survey of Hindu and Muslim voters show that electing a Muslim representative divides Muslim votes across an increased share of coethnic candidates and consolidates Hindu votes for the majoritarian party in the subsequent election. Qualitative evidence and a vignette experiment trace these patterns to two mechanisms: sub-identity activation among Muslims and super-ordinate identity mobilization among Hindus. By showing how representation restructures elite and voter behavior within both minority and dominant groups, the article highlights the dynamic nature of ethnic politics and complicates the view of minorities as politically unified.