↓ 跳过正文

公共行政

Generative Spaces: Collaboration, Learning and Innovation in a Regulatory Sandbox

JPART — 2026-10-01 Original Generative Spaces: Collaboration, Learning and Innovation in a Regulatory Sandbox Carl Macrae, Christopher K Ansell Abstract Abstract Public administrators are increasingly called upon to create “generative spaces” that foster emergent processes of collaboration, learning and innovation. This article presents an inductive and ethnographically grounded study of one relatively novel but increasingly popular generative space—a regulatory sandbox. A regulatory sandbox is a controlled and defined space and set of processes that are established by regulators to work with innovators to collaboratively explore, test and learn about early-stage products and innovations and understand emerging regulatory implications. Investigating a sandbox to explore the regulation of new artificial intelligence technologies conducted by a national healthcare regulator, we identify the organizing practices of the sandbox that make it “generative” of collaboration, learning and innovation. An inductive analysis identified three key organizing practices: providing distinct and varied social spaces separated from normal regulatory demands (protection); enabling participants to collaboratively examine innovations and iteratively develop new knowledge and regulation (adaptation); and supporting focused and immersive examination of innovations from a diverse range of perspectives (participation). A theoretically-driven secondary analysis suggests that generative spaces can be understood as liminal experiences that foster detachment, equivalence and reconstruction.

Can Citizen Pressure Be Induced to Improve Public Service Provision?

JOP 88/4 pp. 1386-1402 2026-10-01 Original Can Citizen Pressure Be Induced to Improve Public Service Provision? Pia J. Raffler, Daniel N. Posner, Doug Parkerson Abstract Encouraging citizens to apply pressure on underperforming service providers has emerged as a prominent response to the failure of states to provide needed services. We outline three theoretical mechanisms through which bottom-up citizen pressure campaigns may affect service provision and investigate them via a large-scale field experiment in the Ugandan health sector. While we find modest positive impacts on health provider behavior, we find no effects on citizen pressure, utilization rates, or bottom-line health outcomes. Our findings cast doubt on the power of outside actors to generate improvements in development outcomes by mobilizing bottom-up pressure—at least under conditions similar to those in our study setting. Our results also underscore the importance of baseline health conditions for the success of bottom-up, citizen-oriented pressure campaigns. Such conditions shape outcomes both across countries and within countries over time, with the latter finding holding important implications for countries undergoing rapid socioeconomic change.

Artificial Intelligence in Policing and Perceived Legitimacy: Does Gender Representation Make a Difference?

PAR — 2026-09-30 Original Artificial Intelligence in Policing and Perceived Legitimacy: Does Gender Representation Make a Difference? Canyu Gao, Norma M. Riccucci Abstract ABSTRACT As artificial intelligence (AI) increasingly transforms public administration, understanding its impact on perceived legitimacy becomes paramount, particularly, in high‐stakes areas such as policing. While existing research offers mixed evidence on whether government AI use enhances or undermines citizens' perceptions of fairness and trust, the conditions moderating these effects remain underexplored. Drawing on representative bureaucracy theory, this study uses a survey experiment to investigate how gender representation moderates the effect of AI use on citizens' perceived fairness and trust in domestic violence units (DVUs). Results show that female representation positively moderates the legitimacy impact of a DVU's AI use; whereas AI use decreases female respondents' perceived fairness and trust in male‐dominated DVUs, these negative effects disappear in female‐dominated DVUs. Our findings identify representation as a key context shaping citizens' responses to government AI use, extending representative bureaucracy theory by demonstrating its indirect symbolic effects.

Reply to Kettl: Beyond Bureaucracy: Why AI Demands a Fourth Way in Public Administration

PAR — 2026-09-29 Original Reply to Kettl: Beyond Bureaucracy: Why AI Demands a Fourth Way in Public Administration Jack Baldwin, Tina Nabatchi Abstract ABSTRACT Kettl argues public administration faces a crisis rooted in widening gaps between scholars and practitioners and between the field's core ideas and current governance issues. We identify a critical example: artificial intelligence (AI) adoption in government. AI fundamentally transforms public organizations, redistributing tasks and discretion between humans and algorithms, embedding instrumental rationality into administrative processes, and reconfiguring authority structures. These developments challenge three longstanding pillars of public administration: bureaucratic neutrality, the politics‐administration dichotomy, and democratic governance. We argue that any proposed “Fourth Way” must center democratic resilience and technological stewardship, incorporating algorithmic transparency requirements and participatory governance structures that preserve public—and especially democratic—values.

Public Management of Deregulated Systems: Challenges and Opportunities in the Public Management of Retail Energy Markets

PAR — 2026-09-29 Original Public Management of Deregulated Systems: Challenges and Opportunities in the Public Management of Retail Energy Markets Noah Dormady, Jenya Kahn‐Lang, Yiseon Choi, Yufan Ji, Samantha Fox, Alberto Lamadrid, Matthew Hoyt

Democratic Accountability with Citizen Coproduction

APSR — pp. 1-19 2026-09-29 Original Democratic Accountability with Citizen Coproduction JIE MA, KEITH E. SCHNAKENBERG, IAN R. TURNER Abstract Many policies require citizens to actively participate in their implementation in order to be successful, a situation referred to as citizen coproduction. Though citizen coproduction is necessary in many policy areas, it could create difficulties for democratic accountability because citizens and politicians share responsibility for policy failures and attribution of blame may be difficult. We analyze the problem of democratic accountability with citizen coproduction in the context of a model in which politicians, who vary with respect to their competence at selecting policies, choose whether to implement policies whose success depends on citizen coproduction choices. For citizens, the problem is one of attribution: when coproduction is low, it may be hard to select good incumbents because policy failures are frequent even when policy choices are good. Incumbents anticipate these effects, which sometimes implies that they are less likely to choose reforms when they are more likely to be successful.

Causes and Consequences of Gendered Bureaucratic Recruitment: A Study of China

JOP — 2026-09-29 Original Causes and Consequences of Gendered Bureaucratic Recruitment: A Study of China Xiaoxia Huang Abstract While the causes and consequences of gender bias are well documented, it remains unclear whether existing theories explain gender dynamics in China's civil service. This study addresses this gap by leveraging original administrative data from the Chinese National Civil Service Examination. The findings show widespread gender bias, with an increased supply of qualified female applicants in prior years prompting hiring authorities, particularly at lower levels of government, to adopt recruitment practices favoring male candidates. These malepreferred practices significantly reshape the candidate pool, reducing its size by 40-45% and lowering candidate quality by 4-5%. These findings deepen our understanding of women's persistent underrepresentation in the Chinese bureaucracy and highlight the substantial costs associated with gendered recruitment practices.