Original
State-sponsored agenda setting: Measuring the impact of narrative laundering
Abstract
Foreign information manipulation and interference (FIMI) is an important part of the digital information ecosystem, yet its effects are poorly understood. Most research analyzing FIMI to date is descriptive, exposing efforts to erode trust, promote favorable narratives, and target specific communities. Existing work evaluating the impacts of FIMI contrasts those directly exposed to FIMI messaging (by viewing the original messages) with those who were not, finding little evidence of changes in beliefs or behavior. Rather than persuading individuals directly, we argue FIMI often operates through agenda-setting processes that shape which issues and narratives dominate public discourse. A key component of this process is narrative laundering, whereby misleading content is scrubbed of its origins and circulated into mainstream channels. This study examines the Russian-aligned Storm-1516 campaign, which uses state media, fabricated sites, and paid influencers to elevate false narratives, especially those that implicate Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy in corrupt acts. By analyzing the dissemination of these narratives, we assess how Storm-1516 shifts the public agenda, illustrating how foreign influence can exert substantial effects on information environments even when individual-level persuasive effects may be limited.
中文
国家支持的议程设置:衡量叙事洗白的影响
摘要
外国信息操纵与干预(FIMI)是数字信息生态系统的重要组成部分,但其影响仍鲜为人知。迄今为止,大多数分析FIMI的研究都是描述性的,揭示了削弱信任、推广有利叙事以及针对特定社群的努力。现有评估FIMI影响的研究将直接接触FIMI信息者(通过查看原始信息)与未接触者进行对比,发现几乎没有证据表明信念或行为发生变化。我们认为,FIMI往往并非直接说服个体,而是通过议程设置过程发挥作用,塑造哪些议题和叙事主导公共话语。这一过程的一个关键组成部分是叙事洗白,即误导性内容被抹去其来源并被传播到主流渠道。本研究考察与俄罗斯结盟的Storm-1516行动,该行动利用国家媒体、伪造网站和付费影响者来提升虚假叙事,尤其是那些暗示乌克兰总统弗拉基米尔·泽连斯基存在腐败行为的叙事。通过分析这些叙事的传播,我们评估Storm-1516如何改变公共议程,说明即使个体层面的说服效果可能有限,外国影响力也能对信息环境产生实质性影响。
关键词
外国信息操纵与干预、叙事洗白、议程设置、Storm-1516、虚假叙事、信息环境、俄罗斯影响力行动