↓ 跳过正文

Polihot

The Myth of the Traditional Gender Gap? Evidence from Catholic Countries

WP 78/3 pp. 459-508 2026-07-01 Original The Myth of the Traditional Gender Gap? Evidence from Catholic Countries Evelyne Brie, Dawn Langan Teele Abstract abstract: In rich democracies today, women are less conservative than men. Yet for most of the twentieth century, politicians, pundits, and scholars believed that family life and religiosity tied women to conservative causes and parties. Recent scholarship has reexamined this traditional gender gap hypothesis but has done so in cases in which electorate-wide shifts to the left make it least likely that a conservative gender gap would emerge. This article scrutinizes a hard case, Quebec, a Catholic province in Canada that experienced a dramatic shift to the right after suffrage. Using Gallup polls and ecological inference techniques, the authors show that political geography drove gender preference gaps, with rural women voting more conservatively, and urban women more liberally, than men. In two other Catholic contexts, Austria and Argentina, they show that after suffrage women were not more conservative than men in general, undermining the traditional gender gap thesis in several crucial cases.

The Minimal Effects of Making Local News Free: Evidence from a Field Experiment

JOP 88/3 pp. 998-1010 2026-07-01 Original The Minimal Effects of Making Local News Free: Evidence from a Field Experiment Andrew Trexler Abstract The collapse of local newspapers has elicited broad concern about citizens’ knowledge of and engagement with local politics. As newspapers struggle, many have retreated behind online paywalls—which limit access to political information that is essential for democracy. Does making local news free to access induce its consumption? And, if so, does that consumption produce salutary effects on citizen knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors? I provide evidence from a pre-registered, randomized field experiment, which provided a probability-based sample of North Carolina registered voters with a free digital subscription to a local newspaper for two months during the 2022 general election. The free subscriptions did not meaningfully increase consumption, nor produce meaningful changes in political knowledge, attitudes, or behaviors. Price is but one of several obstacles to news consumption, and disparities in citizen knowledge and engagement with local politics are unlikely to be addressed by making some local journalism available for free.

The Hidden Universe of Operationalizing Natural Experiments: Navigating Extreme Weather

JOP 88/3 pp. 1186-1201 2026-07-01 Original The Hidden Universe of Operationalizing Natural Experiments: Navigating Extreme Weather Franziska Quoß, Lukas Rudolph Abstract Natural or quasi-experimental research designs are based on exogenous variation, oftentimes requiring operationalization before use in statistical tests. For this, researchers regularly lack clear theoretical guidance and need to make threshold decisions. We show for three types of shocks—extreme weather, immigration exposure, and commodity price changes—that this leads to a vast menu of equally plausible measurements, which are used unsystematically in ensuing literatures. This hidden universe of operationalization decisions has consequences: Drawing on geocoded survey and weather panel data for Switzerland, we show that different measurements of extreme weather exposure exhibit vast statistical and geographical variation. Importantly, researchers can support arbitrary conclusions when using singular operationalizations, while, in our case, the whole set indicates robust null effects. These results highlight that measurement decisions induce relevant researcher degrees of freedom rarely made transparent. We consequently discuss how current practice could improve, concluding with a template and recommendations.

The Gender Gap in Political Careers Under Proportional Representation

JOP 88/3 pp. 935-951 2026-07-01 Original The Gender Gap in Political Careers Under Proportional Representation Tobias Nowacki Abstract (原文未提供摘要) 中文 比例代表制下的政治生涯性别差距 Tobias Nowacki 摘要 原文未提供摘要 关键词 性别差距、政治生涯、比例代表制、选举制度、政治代表 DOI: 10.1086/735871 查看原文 →

The Church as Arbiter: A Divided Right in Interwar France

JOP 88/3 pp. 1027-1047 2026-07-01 Original The Church as Arbiter: A Divided Right in Interwar France Carles Boix, Jean Lacroix Abstract To document the impact of elites’ choices on political movements, we leverage the condemnation of L’Action Française (AF), a monarchist movement, by Pope Pius XI in 1926. As a consequence of the papal condemnation, French Catholics had to choose between their involvement in AF and accessing Catholic sacraments. Difference-in-differences estimates show that the papal condemnation reshaped AF’s territorial distribution and social basis, weakening its support in religious areas while attracting more secularized followers. Following that shift, AF mutated from being a conservative nationalist movement with strong Catholic connections to an extreme organization entangled with a violent and anti-parliamentarian right. Our examination of the role of elites in the development of political movements allows us to shed new light on the dynamics that resulted in the collapse of democracy in interwar Europe.

The Answer Was There All Along: Worry About the Dynamics!

JOP 88/3 pp. 1216-1230 2026-07-01 Original The Answer Was There All Along: Worry About the Dynamics! Ali Kagalwala, Guy D. Whitten Abstract In an influential article in 1974, Clive Granger and Paul Newbold demonstrated that regressions with variables that have unit roots often lead to spurious inferences. However, researchers have overlooked the fact that Granger and Newbold’s results were from a static time series model plagued with residual autocorrelation. We demonstrate, analytically and through simulations, that, under most circumstances, adding lags of both the outcome and predictor(s) can account for serial correlation and avoid spurious inferences. We thus recommend the use of a general modeling strategy, an autoregressive distributed lag model with multiple lags of the outcome and predictor(s), as one possible alternative of model choice that is less likely than other commonly used models to reach incorrect conclusions about true effects. Furthermore, our recommended approach performs well relative to the Webb, Linn, and Lebo bounds approach, the latest in a series of techniques designed to avoid the problematic nature of unit root testing.

State surveillance and collective dissent

AJPS — 2026-07-01 Original State surveillance and collective dissent Gaétan Nandong Abstract Abstract State surveillance facilitates the collection of intelligence on dissidents while simultaneously providing information about the value of the status quo. I study this trade‐off in a context where an uninformed government must decide whether to repress. Because citizens expect more informed governments to enact greater repression, autocratic surveillance can create a climate of fear. However, surveillance can also stimulate dissent when citizens have access to public information. State surveillance gives citizens an opportunity to coordinate, even in the absence of a preference for such coordination. Surveillance can amplify dissent by enhancing citizens' motivations for political activism aimed at drawing the government's attention to political and economic issues. Coordination distorts government learning, resulting in lower expected levels of repression. The analysis further indicates that the effectiveness of advanced surveillance technology depends on expectations regarding repression, thereby underscoring a psychological aspect of state control.